News

Hiring Women With Convictions Could Fix Care Staff Shortage

empowering women addressing shortages

In short: It could help. Adult social care in England had about 96,000 vacant posts in 2025/26, while women leaving prison are far less likely than men to find work. Care employers can recruit safely using enhanced DBS checks and free help from the government's New Futures Network.

Hiring women with criminal records could help ease care sector staffing shortages. Adult social care in England had about 96,000 vacant posts on any given day in 2025/26, a vacancy rate of 6.2%, according to Skills for Care. At the same time, women with convictions find it especially hard to get work after prison. Employers who practise fair chance hiring report loyal, long-serving staff, and free government help is available. This untapped workforce could help fill care roles and reduce reoffending. While many employers hesitate to hire people with criminal records, women with convictions face even steeper challenges in finding work after prison. Ministry of Justice figures show that only 20.1% of people leaving prison were in work six weeks after release, and 34.5% after six months (May 2024 to March 2025). Women fare worse than men: a Prison Reform Trust and Working Chance briefing found women were nearly three times less likely than men to be in work six weeks after release. Women have nearly twice the likelihood of having criminal records disclosed during job applications compared to men. This matters, because a job is one of the strongest supports for staying away from crime. The care and childcare sectors are short of staff. These mainly female workforces could benefit from hiring suitable women with convictions. Roles such as care assistants, home carers and childcare workers often stay unfilled while capable women struggle to find work because of their past. Criminal record checks are part of the picture. Most care jobs involve close work with adults who need support, so employers can ask for an enhanced DBS check, which can include spent convictions that haven't been filtered and a check of the adults' barred list. A conviction doesn't automatically rule someone out: employers are expected to have a fair policy on recruiting people with convictions and to weigh up how relevant an offence is to the role and how long ago it happened. Despite these hurdles, hiring people with convictions has worked well for many employers. In the United States, Johns Hopkins Hospital hired 97 people with records, and 96% remained employed after four years. Butterball Farms, a US manufacturer, reports a 93% retention rate for second chance hires compared to 67% overall. These examples suggest that employees with convictions often show strong loyalty and performance. In the UK, there is no tax credit for hiring people with convictions, but free help is available. The New Futures Network, the employment team in HM Prison and Probation Service, matches employers with prisons and probation to recruit people towards the end of their sentence, and can help screen out offences that would be unsuitable for a role. Charities such as Working Chance specialise in helping women with convictions into work. Hiring women with convictions can benefit whole communities. Steady work helps people leaving prison rebuild their lives, and it provides stability for families who often depend on women as their main carers. Additionally, employing women with convictions could help address the care sector's staffing shortage while providing them access to Carer Friendly Card benefits that support their integration into the workforce. Forward-thinking employers are addressing the care staff shortage by tapping into this underused workforce. By implementing fair chance hiring practices and providing adequate training, companies can simultaneously address labour needs and create meaningful second chances for women working to rebuild their lives after prison. This approach aligns with research showing diverse perspectives offered by people with convictions can enhance workplace dynamics and organisational effectiveness.

Sources

Looking into care for someone? Compare care homes near you →

CS

Claire Saltwater

Editor · AskBart

Claire Saltwater is AskBart's Editor and a care-home industry veteran. One of AskBart's earliest team members, she has spent years working in and around social care — so she understands first-hand the difficult, often overwhelming decisions families face when choosing a care home. Claire writes and edits AskBart's advice guides with one goal: clear, genuinely independent information, free of jargon and sales pressure. Away from her desk she loves a good farmers' market and time with her two young children.

Keep reading

Need personal guidance?

Talk to an advisor

Our care experts are here to help you make the right choice — for free.

Get in touch

Keep up with care news

Rating changes and vacancies near you, a new guide and one money fact, in one short email every other Thursday. Free.

Bart’s fortnightly: care news near you, a new guide and one money fact, every other Thursday. Unsubscribe any time.